Mobile version
WeChat
Facebook
Twitter
Instagram
YouTube
App

For Canada and China, real work starts after Shenzhen

Mark Carney disembarks from an aircraft upon his arrival at Shenzhen Bao'an International Airport ahead of the APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting in Shenzhen on November 16, 2026.

Prime Minister Mark Carney arrived at the APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting in Shenzhen ten months after his January visit to Beijing. With the thawing of Canada-China relations, some observers may expect positive announcements this week. Indeed, during Carney's visit to Shenzhen, China announced that it would further reduce or eliminate tariffs on Canadian exports, including frozen pork, fish and seafood, with a total value of approximately C$400 million.

In exchange, Canada has agreed to extend existing tariff relief measures for certain Chinese steel and aluminum products by two years. These measures were originally set to expire at the end of 2026.

At the leadership level, progress has been considerable. In January, the two governments issued a joint statement and a trade roadmap that commit them to cooperating on energy, agriculture and investment. They signed an energy memorandum and held their first Ministerial Dialogue on Energy on November 4. That same week, they agreed to extend two tariff relief measures to the end of 2028.

The most visible change concerns electric vehicles. On March 1, Canada removed its 100 percent surtax on Chinese-made EVs and set an initial quota of 49,000 vehicles a year. Though the quota is less than 3 percent of Canada's new vehicle sales, the decision flies in the face of US expectations, and the US president threatened tariffs on Canadian goods in response. It showed that Canada is prepared to act in its own interests.

Leaders have endorsed the two tariff relief extensions. More announcements are possible in Shenzhen. What is clear is that the leaders of both countries are opening the doors to greater prosperity for the two nations. To take full advantage, businesses, investors and provincial governments need to walk through the doorway. Right now, many are not. One reason is that Chinese businesses and investors face a sluggish Canadian bureaucracy and unclear rules, which make investing in Canada riskier than it needs to be.

Electric vehicles are the clearest example. Only 15,603 vehicles had entered Canada by September. Before a Chinese brand can sell here, Transport Canada must certify that its vehicles meet Canadian safety standards. In its agreement with China, Ottawa pledged "timely vehicle certification." By Canadian standards, "timely" means a year or longer. BYD, Chery and Geely have scaled back their Canadian expansion plans, and launches planned for late 2026 have moved to 2027. An estimated 97 percent of the Chinese-made vehicles imported this year were Teslas built in Shanghai. National leaders made their commitment in January, but it has not been delivered at the working level.

The largest opportunity for the two countries is oil, and here too Canadian regulation is unclear and poorly coordinated. The United States buys 90 percent of Canada's crude oil exports, so China is an obvious diversification market for Canada. China bought about half of the cargoes shipped from the Trans Mountain terminal at the Port of Vancouver between May 2024 and June 2025. The proposed West Coast Oil Pipeline, from Alberta to the British Columbia coast, would add one million barrels per day of export capacity.

Canada's energy minister, Tim Hodgson, has said Canada is "open to additional investment in the energy sector by China" and has not ruled out majority stakes by Chinese state-owned companies. There is precedent: China National Offshore Oil Corporation and PetroChina Company Limited both operate oil sands projects in Alberta.

At the same time, it is far from clear how Canada's government assesses Chinese investment under the Investment Canada Act. The Act allows any foreign investment to be reviewed on national security grounds and gives the government wide discretion to block deals. It also applies closer scrutiny to state-owned investors, whatever the size of the transaction.

Enforcement of the Investment Canada Act can be severe. Canada's new national security strategy, released in October, adds to the uncertainty. It makes economic security "a primary factor in decisions on industrial support, innovation and foreign investment" and promises "stronger enforcement tools." It does not say what this means for Chinese investors. That is a serious obstacle for anyone considering a project such as the West Coast Oil Pipeline, which an industry estimate puts at C$35.2 billion. 

National flags of Canada and China

The opportunity for Chinese and Canadian businesses to work together is large, and both governments support it. Chinese businesses and investors need to look behind the leaders' announcements and think about implementation at the working level.

Chinese firms should carefully look at the rules they will have to meet in Canada before they commit. They should also understand that Canadian governments and regulators may have less capacity than those in China, making them slower and less responsive. Firms that plan for this, with local expertise, are the most likely to succeed.

In the end, the greater risk lies with Canada. Canadian leaders and working-level officials need to realize that the world will not wait for us to make up our minds on how to structure our national security rules. Investors have little patience for ambiguity and reversals.

That said, with Mr. Carney at the helm, there is hope for improvement. His government has created a Major Projects Office and introduced legislation that sets a one-year target for federal project reviews and decisions. With some luck, these actions will set Canada up to take full advantage of the doors being opened to it.

Photos: CFP

Author: Robin Shaban, an economist and partner at 2R Strategy, a Canadian strategy consultancy

Related News